Naomi Garner is a competitor on Survivor: Madagascar, Survivor: All-Stars, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, Survivor: Familial Values, and Survivor: Legends.

In Survivor: Madagascar, Naomi became a notable player because of her excellent social game. Her ability to make friends with all of her original Tribemates allowed her to make the merge, but this same positive aspect became a flaw, as she was seen as a jury threat and was voted out as the first jury member.

Naomi returned in Survivor: All-Stars, where she was remembered for her excellent social skills. It was because of this that she was targeted first and subsequently became the first returning player ever to be voted out of the game.

She returned again as a Hero in Survivor:  Heroes vs Villains,  and remained constantly fearful of being voted out early a second time. She came under the wing of Florence Banks and Cordelia Aiello, working with them to maintain her safety in the game. At the merge, Naomi felt comfortable with her former allies still in the competition, but the Villains alliance overcame her, eliminating her once again as the first juror.

Naomi made her grand return in Survivor: Familial Values along with her husband, Jeffery. After being voted out first, Naomi assumed an extremely aggressive approach to Redemption Island, winning almost every duel and returning to the game. At the merge, Naomi ensured that she would not be the first juror by forming alliances with all players she knew were previously at the bottom of the game. She formed a great bond with Jolene Delarosa and made it all the way to the final six, where she was blindside cruelly, but managed to return to the game again and attempted to overthrow Jolene. This failed, however, as she was voted out immediately after returning in fifth place.

Naomi made a triumphant return in Survivor: Legends, making her one of two people to ever play for a fifth time at the time of filming. Naomi's legacy was mostly for her run in Familial Values, and she began the game with a minimally aggressive approach. She formed an alliance with Tony Burns, Nadine Williamson, Florence Banks, and Ronnie Burton. After making it through to the merge, Naomi flew safely under the radar with Nadine Williamson, ultimately taking charge of her alliance. However, she was blindsided when Nadine flipped on her to take control of the game.


Naomi's Voting History
Episode Voted For Voted Against
1 Gloria;
2 Henry -
3 Soalala Tribe Immune
4 Juan;
5 Soalala Tribe Immune
6 Ervin -
7 Irene -
8 Juan Ervin, Juan, Maurice,
Ivan, Norman
Voted Out, Day 24
Voted For
Sole Survivor

All StarsEdit

Naomi's Voting History
Episode Voted For Voted Against
1 Verna Tony, Florence, Danny,
Verna, Opal, Cedric
Voted Out, Day 3

Heroes vs VillainsEdit

Naomi's Voting History
Episode Voted For Voted Against
1 Amos -
2 Heroes Tribe Immune
3 Heroes Tribe Immune
4 Carolyn -
5 Heroes Tribe Immune
6 Heroes Tribe Immune
7 Trinidad -
8 Malcolm -
9 Jeremiah -
10 Tony Terrence, Tony, Jeremiah,
Vicki, Jolene, Erich, Lindsey
Voted Out, Day 26
Voted For
Sole Survivor

Familial ValuesEdit

Naomi's Voting History
Episode Voted For Voted Against
1 Percy Bradley, Violet, Marcus,
Prince, Garland, May,
Genevieve, Percy
Voted Out, Day 3
2 On Redemption Island
Returned, Day 20
8 Harley Individual Immunity
9 Prince -
10 Garland -
11 Olympia -
12 Jolene;
13 May -
Jonathan Individual Immunity
14 Percy Jolene, Stephen, Ronnie,
Voted Out, Day 34
15 On Redemption Island
Returned, Day 35
15 Jolene Jolene, Stephen, Ronnie
Voted Out, Day 37

Voted For
Sole Survivor



Naomi's Voting History
Episode Voted For Voted Against
1 Samarinda Tribe Immune
Samarinda Tribe Immune
2 Samarinda Tribe Immune
3 Terrence -
4 Ashlee -
5 Keningau Tribe Immune
6 Keningau Tribe Immune
7 Reed Reed, Jordan
8 Samarinda Tribe Immune
9 Melissa -
10 Hannah; Cordelia, Percy, Jeremiah,
Vicki, Christopher, Hannah
Voted Out, Day 27
Voted For
Sole Survivor

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.